The AI Tutor Experiment: How Families Are Using ChatGPT to Boost Grades — And the Unexpected Drawbacks

Start learning AI in 2025

Keeping up with AI is hard – we get it!

That’s why over 1M professionals read Superhuman AI to stay ahead.

• Get daily AI news, tools, and tutorials

• Learn new AI skills you can use at work in 3 mins a day

• Become 10X more productive

Sign up and start mastering AI

When 16-year-old Ethan was struggling with AP Chemistry last semester, his parents considered hiring a private tutor—at $85 per hour. Instead, his father, a software engineer, suggested a different approach: using ChatGPT as a personalized, on-demand tutor. Three months later, Ethan's grade had improved from a C- to a B+, and his conceptual understanding had deepened significantly.

"It was like having a patient tutor available whenever I needed help, even at 11 PM before a test," Ethan explains. "I could ask the same question multiple different ways until I actually understood the concept, without feeling judged."

Across the country, families like Ethan's are discovering the academic potential of AI language models as personalized tutoring tools. From elementary school parents guiding homework sessions to high school students preparing for AP exams, the use of AI as an educational resource has exploded. A recent survey by the Education Technology Consortium found that 37% of parents in high-performing school districts report their children regularly use AI tools for academic support—a seven-fold increase from just a year ago.

The appeal is obvious: 24/7 availability, infinite patience, and zero judgment—all at a fraction of the cost of traditional tutoring. But educators and child development experts warn that this educational revolution comes with both promising benefits and concerning pitfalls that parents need to navigate carefully.

How Families Are Using AI Tutors

Parents and students have developed diverse approaches to leveraging AI for academic support:

Concept Explanation

Many students use AI to explain challenging concepts in alternative ways when they don't understand classroom instruction or textbook explanations. By requesting simpler language, different analogies, or connecting ideas to personal interests, students get customized explanations that traditional resources can't provide.

Fourteen-year-old Maya describes her approach: "When I don't understand something in math, I take a picture of the problem and ask ChatGPT to explain it step-by-step, then to explain it again using a real-world example that relates to basketball, which helps me remember it better."

Homework Support

Parents, particularly those who feel ill-equipped to help with unfamiliar academic content, increasingly use AI as a "co-teacher" during homework sessions. Rather than providing answers, thoughtful parents prompt AI to offer guided hints, Socratic questioning, or verification of a child's work.

"I struggled trying to help my daughter with her new math curriculum because it's taught so differently from how I learned," explains Rachel Martinez, mother of a fourth-grader. "Now I ask ChatGPT to explain the methodology first, then to provide practice problems similar to her homework. It's transformed our formerly stressful homework sessions."

Essay Development and Feedback

For writing assignments, some students use AI to brainstorm ideas, outline arguments, provide feedback on drafts, or suggest clearer phrasing—essentially replicating the writing conference experience typically limited by teacher availability.

"I always had ideas but struggled to organize them," shares high school junior Lily Chen. "I use AI to help structure my thoughts and get feedback on my logical flow before submitting assignments. My writing has improved dramatically."

Test Preparation

As exams approach, many students leverage AI to create customized practice tests, explain incorrect answers, or simulate Socratic tutoring sessions on specific topics. The ability to generate unlimited practice materials tailored to individual needs has proven particularly valuable.

Complex Problem Decomposition

For advanced students, AI helps break down complex, multi-step problems into manageable components. This scaffolding approach is particularly helpful in subjects like physics, advanced mathematics, or computer science.

The Measurable Benefits

Early research on academically-focused AI usage shows promising results:

A six-month study conducted by researchers at the University of Pennsylvania examined 245 high school students using AI tutoring supplements compared to a control group using traditional study methods. The AI-assisted group showed:

• 22% greater improvement in subject comprehension assessments

• Higher rates of homework completion

• Increased confidence in tackling challenging material

• More sophisticated question-asking behaviors

• Greater persistence when facing difficult concepts

"The students who benefited most were those who previously lacked access to academic support at home," notes Dr. James Williams, who led the study. "AI tools appear to have significant potential for narrowing achievement gaps when used thoughtfully."

The Concerning Downsides

Despite these benefits, education and development experts express significant concerns about unmonitored AI usage for academic purposes:

Dependency and Skill Atrophy

"We're seeing students who've become so dependent on AI assistance that they've lost confidence in their independent abilities," warns Dr. Elena Rodriguez, educational psychologist and author of "Digital Natives, Digital Wisdom."

The most problematic pattern involves students who use AI to complete work rather than to learn how to complete work—essentially outsourcing thinking rather than enhancing it. This pattern can lead to underdeveloped academic muscles and false confidence.

Critical Thinking Bypass

When AI provides immediate answers or highly structured frameworks, students may skip the valuable cognitive struggle that builds critical thinking and problem-solving capabilities.

"There's substantial evidence that productive struggle is essential for deep learning," explains cognitive scientist Dr. Michael Chen. "When AI removes that struggle entirely rather than appropriately scaffolding it, students miss crucial developmental processes."

Academic Integrity Boundaries

Perhaps most concerning to educators is the blurring of academic integrity boundaries. A recent anonymous survey of high school students found that 42% admitted to submitting AI-generated work as their own at least once, with many failing to recognize this as a form of plagiarism.

"Students need explicit guidance about where helpful collaboration ends and academic dishonesty begins," notes high school principal Sandra Thompson. "Many genuinely don't understand the ethical boundaries in this new terrain."

Factual Reliability

AI language models can present incorrect information with absolute confidence—a phenomenon experts call "hallucination." When students lack the knowledge to identify these errors, they may internalize misconceptions that undermine accurate understanding.

"We had a student who consistently answered questions incorrectly on an astronomy test because the AI tool had given him outdated and simply wrong information about exoplanets," shares science teacher Robert Johnson. "He was absolutely convinced his answers were correct because 'the AI said so.'"

Expert Guidelines for Parents

Education and technology experts recommend specific parameters to maximize benefits while minimizing risks:

1. Establish Clear Purpose Boundaries

Dr. Rodriguez recommends parents explicitly categorize AI usage into "learning support" versus "performance support" and establish appropriate boundaries for each:

• Learning support (concept explanation, practice generation, feedback on drafts) generally benefits skill development

• Performance support (generating content, completing assignments, writing papers) generally undermines skill development

"The key question is whether the AI is helping your child become a more capable, independent thinker or simply doing the thinking for them," she explains.

2. Implement the "Second Draft Rule"

For written assignments, many educators recommend a "second draft rule"—students can use AI for feedback on work they've already created but must implement changes themselves rather than accepting AI-generated content wholesale.

"This approach teaches revision skills while preventing direct plagiarism," notes English teacher Maria Gonzalez.

3. Focus on Question Formulation

Parents can transform AI interactions into critical thinking exercises by focusing on how students formulate their questions.

"I have my children write out what they're going to ask the AI before they type it," shares father of three David Kim. "Then we discuss how to make the question more specific or how to ask for an explanation that will deepen understanding rather than just provide an answer."

This approach develops the metacognitive skill of knowing what you don't know—a capability that distinguishes sophisticated learners.

4. Practice Fact-Checking

Teaching children to verify AI-provided information against reliable sources builds crucial digital literacy skills. Some families implement a "trust but verify" approach, requiring independent confirmation of key facts or concepts.

5. Model Appropriate Usage

Perhaps most importantly, parents who use AI tools themselves should demonstrate ethical and thoughtful usage.

"Children are watching how we use these tools," reminds Dr. Chen. "If they see us using AI to genuinely learn and enhance our thinking rather than to cut corners, they're more likely to develop healthy usage patterns themselves."

Finding Balance

As with most technological innovations, the impact of AI tutoring tools ultimately depends on how they're used. When implemented thoughtfully, they can democratize access to high-quality academic support and personalize learning in unprecedented ways. When used carelessly, they can undermine the development of independent thinking and academic integrity.

For Ethan, the chemistry student, the experience taught valuable lessons about both chemistry and learning itself. "I realized that understanding why something works is much more important than just getting the right answer," he reflects. "The best way to use AI is to ask it to explain concepts until I can explain them myself without help. That's when I know I've actually learned something."

His father adds a perspective many parents share: "These tools aren't going away—they'll only become more powerful and pervasive. Our job isn't to restrict access but to teach thoughtful usage. The students who learn how to leverage AI appropriately rather than depend on it completely will have an enormous advantage moving forward."